Ask a question

Questions & answers · Car insurance

My insurer offered $8,000 for my totaled car but Kelley Blue Book says $12,000. What can I do?

Car insurancePaid too littleChecked Nov 6, 2026

From K.Actuary, founded by Sangmin Kwon, ASA · sources checked 2026-11-06 · Source: Texas Department of Insurance View original ↗

In short

  1. Ask what source the company used for your car's value [1].
  2. You can try to negotiate by showing local prices as proof [2].
  3. List special features or custom parts, and keep every quote [2].

What this means

First, find out where the number came from. The Texas department says the company looks at the value of your car against the cost to repair it, and that you can ask the insurance company what source it used to decide your car's value [1]. Put that in writing. Ask for the valuation report, the cars it compared, and its adjustments.

Then build your own case. The department says that if you think your car is worth more, you can try to negotiate. Be prepared to show what the car would sell for in your area. Get quotes from used car dealers. View prices online and look for local ads for similar vehicles. Document any special features or custom parts [2]. Those four things are the proof this page asks for.

One more thing. Do you want to keep the car? Tell the company as soon as possible, because it will subtract the car's salvage value from the amount it was planning to pay you [3].

Your next step

Write to the insurer and ask for the valuation report and the source it used [1]. Gather dealer quotes, online prices and local ads for similar vehicles, plus receipts for special features, and send them with a written counter-offer [2]. Do you want to keep the car? Say so now, because salvage value is subtracted [3]. These sources give no deadline for negotiating, so check your policy.

Check it yourself

Open the TDI page "My car was totaled! Now what?" Read three parts. What "totaled" means. What to do if you think the car is worth more. And "Can I fix it?" Then ask your insurer for the valuation report. Put the cars it used next to local listings.

Where this comes from (3)

  1. [1] Texas Department of Insurance · checked 2026-11-06

    The insurance company will look at the value of your car vs. the cost to repair it. If the cost to repair the car is about the same or more than the value of your car, the insurance company will likely consider it totaled. Some companies might total your car even if the cost to fix it is lower. You can ask the insurance company what source it used to decide your car's value.

  2. [2] Texas Department of Insurance · checked 2026-11-06

    If you think your car is worth more than what the insurance company decided, you can try to negotiate. Be prepared to show what the car would sell for in your area. Get quotes from used car dealers. View prices online and look for local ads for similar vehicles. Document any special features or custom parts on your car.

  3. [3] Texas Department of Insurance · checked 2026-11-06

    If you want to keep your car, let the insurance company know as soon as possible. The insurance company will subtract the car's salvage value from the amount it was planning to pay you.

How we found this

We matched your question to 3 official sources, quoted the exact lines, and re-checked each quote against its source on 2026-11-06.

What we don’t know yet

Your own plan or notice may say something different. If your letter cites another rule, send it and we will look again.

Every answer is checked against the official rule it quotes.

Information only — not legal advice. Your plan, insurer or agency decides.

This answer quotes the official sources listed above, with the date we checked them. Your own policy, notice and state rules control. We are not your lawyer or your insurer. We don’t file, argue or negotiate claims for you — you send any letter or form yourself.

Ask a questionCompare pricesGet help with my claim

Related answers

Answer id CQ2130. Spotted an error? Tell us.